Collective Management Reform: A Long Road to LMK Transparency and Accountability

Muhamad Syahnakri; Dewa Krisna  Prasada

doi:10.25139/lex journal.v9i2.10365

Muhamad Syahnakri Faculty of Law, Universitas Pendidikan Nasional, Indonesia
Dewa Krisna Prasada Faculty of Law, Universitas Pendidikan Nasional, Indonesia

https://doi.org/10.25139/lex%20journal.v9i2.10365

Abstract views: 56 ,

PDF downloads: 16

Keywords: Collective Management Organizations (LMK), Royalty Transparency, Copyright Governance, Creative Economy, Blockchain in Copyright Law

Abstract

This article targets legal scholars, copyright regulators, and stakeholders in the creative economy by critically analyzing Indonesia's collective rights management system, specifically the operational framework of Collective Management Organizations (LMK) as established by Law No. 28/2014 and Government Regulation No. 56/2021. The paper examines the normative deficiencies and governance inefficiencies in royalty administration, posing the legal inquiry: To what degree can Indonesia's copyright system guarantee transparency, equity, and accountability in the distribution of royalties to creators? This book demonstrates, through normative legal methodologies and comparative analysis with Japan's JASRAC model, that the lack of participatory mechanisms, unclear royalty tariff-setting, and inadequate technological infrastructure have undermined the LMK's legitimacy and its function of distributive justice. This research offers novel insights by advocating for legal reforms that incorporate public input, graduated royalty structures, and blockchain-enabled tracking. It connects formal copyright law with practical creative work, enhancing discussions on procedural fairness, regulatory involvement, and fair digital governance in copyright administration.

References

BOOK

Marzuki, Peter Mahmud, Penelitian Hukum (jakarta: Prenadamedia Group, 2015).

Pratiwi, Cekli Setya & Febriansyah Ramadhan, Hukum Hak Asasi Manusia Teori dan Studi Kasus (Malang: UMM Press, 2023).

JOURNAL

Aisyah Nurraihanah, Dessy Maeyangsari, “Jurnal Darma Agung” (2022) 32:6 J Darma Agung 105–123.

Aliansyah, Mohamad Alen, “Tinjauan Normatif Kedudukan Lembaga Manajemen Kolektif Nasional (LMKN) sebagai State Auxiliary Organ berdasarkan Peraturan Pemerintah No. 56 Tahun 2021 tentang Pengelolan Royalti Hak Cipta Lagu dan/atau Musik” (2022) 13:2 Dialogia Iurid 001–020.

Andry Setiawan, Muchammad Shidqon Prabowo, “Implementasi Lembaga Manajemen” in Huk dan Polit dalam Berbagai Perspekt (Semarang: Universitas Negeri Semarang, 2023) 24.

Annisa Putri Nadya, “Kekuatan Lembaga Manajemen Kolektif Nasional Dalam Penarikan Royalti” (2023) 1:4 Jaksa J Kaji Ilmu Huk dan Polit 142–149.

Anzani, Ardil, Ma’ruf Hafidz & Hasbuddin Khalid, “LEGAL REVIEW OF WITHDRAWALS OF ROYALTIES BY COPYRIGHT MANAGEMENT INSTITUTIONS AND FOUNDATION OF COPYRIGHT INDONESIA BY ACCORDING TO LAW NUMBER 28 OF 2014 ON COPYRIGHT INSTITUTIONS” (2020) 3:3 Meraja J 97–109.

Asihatka, Prima Tiara Muthi’ah Rizky, “LISENSI ROYALTI PENGGUNAAN HAK CIPTA LAGU UNTUK KEPENTINGAN YANG BERSIFAT KOMERSIAL” (2024) 8:2 BORNEO Law Rev 113–126.

Barth, Matthew et al, “Carsharing and station cars in Asia: Overview of Japan and Singapore” (2006) 2:1986 Transp Res Rec 106–115.

Damarsasongko, Agung & Endang Pandamdari, “PENGELOLAAN ROYALTI KARYA CIPTA LAGU DAN/ATAU MUSIK ATAS CIPTAAN YANG TIDAK DIKETAHUI PENCIPTANYA (ORPHAN WORKS)” (2023) I:September J Lege Ferenda Trisakti 80–86.

Dewi, Ratna et al, “JICN: Jurnal Intelek dan Cendikiawan Nusantara PERLINDUNGAN HAK CIPTA DALAM PERDAGANGAN DIGITAL TANTANGAN DAN PROSPEK DALAM PERSPEKTIF HUKUM PERDATA COPYRIGHT PROTECTION IN DIGITAL COMMERCE CHALLENGES AND PROSPECTS IN A CIVIL LAW PERSPECTIVE” (2024) 1:2 3122–3129.

Faludi, Gabor, “Collective Management of Copyright in Hungary1” in Cambridge Handb Intellect Prop Cent East Eur (Cambridge University Press, 2019) 147.

Febriansyah Ramadhan, Deny Noer Wahid & Nabil Nizam, “Hubungan Negara Dan Agama: Telaah Hukum Dan Putusan Pengadilan” (2023) 2:1 JAPHTN-HAN.

Graber, Christoph B, “Is there potential for collective rights management at the global level? Perspectives of a new global constitutionalism in the creative sector” in Evol Equilib Copyr Digit Age (Cambridge University Press, 2014) 241.

Hadiati, Mia et al, “Efektivitas Putusan Mahkamah Konstitusi Nomor 22/Puu-Xv/2017 Tentang Batas Usia Perkawinan” (2021) 5:1 J Muara Ilmu Sos Humaniora, dan Seni 300–310.

Handoko, Windy Fariskya & Kholis Roisah, “Pengelolaan Royalti Hak Cipta Lagu dan Musik : Studi Kasus Pada Bisnis Karaoke” (2024) 6:3 UNES Law Rev 9561–9571.

Hayati, Dina, “PENERAPAN ROYALTI DI BIDANG MUSIK DAN LAGU TERHADAP ERA DIGITAL” (2024) 7:1 J Sos Hum Sigli 256–265.

Indratmo, Kadenza Adistya Tamara, “Tinjauan Hukum Perlindungan Hak Cipta Film Dokumenter Dan Peluang Hak Ekonomi Insan Perfilman Dokumenter Di Indonesia” (2022) 1:1 Technol Econ Law J 81–96.

Irfan Hibatullah, Annalisa Y, M Syaifuddin, Putu Samawati, Kn Sofyan Hasan, “Tantangan Pengikatan Hak Cipta Sebagai Agunan Kredit Perbankan di Indonesia” (2023) 3:4 Innov J Soc Sci Res 7611–7622.

Isac, Florin Lucian & Eugen Florin Remeş, “Tradition Vs. Modernity in Japanese Management” (2020) 30:1 Stud Univ Vasile Goldis Arad, Econ Ser 76–90.

Kartikasari, Dina & Saiful Risky, “The Idea of Independent Judicial Ethics Courts in Indonesia” (2025) 4:1 JAPHTN-HAN 65–85.

Kurniawan, Fredy Bagus, Marsitiningsih, “Penegakan Hukum Terhadap Pelanggaran Hak Cipta Musik pada Konser Komersial ( Studi Kasus Once dengan Dewa 19 )” (2025) 8:2 PAGARUYUANG Law J 155–169.

Mabillard, Vincent & Raphael Zumofen, “The complex relationship between transparency and accountability: A synthesis and contribution to existing frameworks” (2017) 32:2 Public Policy Adm 110–129.

Mabillard, Vincent & Raphaël Zumofen, “Transparency and Accountability—The Case of Public Procurement Practices in Switzerland” (2021) 26:2 Public Work Manag Policy 95–114.

Masyhuri, Muhammad, Ahsana Nadiyya & Gresika Bunga Sylvana, “The Urgency of Regulating Resale Royalty Right on Painting Copyrights in Indonesia (Comparative Study of Germany and Australia)” (2023) 4:3 J Law Leg Reform 365–398.

Muthmainnah, Nafisah, Praxedis Ajeng Pradita & Cika Alfiah Putri Abu Bakar, “PERLINDUNGAN HUKUM TERHADAP HAK CIPTA BIDANG LAGU DAN/ATAU MUSIK BERDASARKAN PP NOMOR 56 TAHUN 2021 TENTANG PENGELOLAAN ROYALTI HAK CIPTA LAGU DAN/ATAU MUSIK” (2022) 10:1 Padjadjaran Law Rev.

Njatrijani, Rinitami et al, “Era Digital Melahirkan Peran Baru, Aggregator Musik Dalam Mendistribusikan Karya Cipta Lagu Dan Musik” (2020) 7:1 Diponegoro Priv Law Rev 689–699.

Peréz Gómez, Ana María & Maria Alejandra Echavarría Arcila, “Collective administration of online rights in musical works: Analysing the economic efficiency of the Directive 2014/26/EU” (2014) 7:3–4 Int J Intellect Prop Manag 103–119.

Pramanto, Wahyu Jati, “OPTIMALISASI PENARIKAN DAN PENDISTRIBUSIAN ROYALTI HAK CIPTA OLEH LEMBAGA MANAJEMEN KOLEKTIF NASIONAL” (2022) 1:2 WICARANA 93–104.

Qinlong, Huang et al, “Towards an Efficient and Secure Online Digital Rights Management Scheme in Cloud Computing” (2014) 8:1 Int J Secur Its Appl 159–168.

Rafianti, Laina, Aam Suryamah & Jeremia Lumban Tobing, “KIPRAH LEMBAGA MANAJEMEN KOLEKTIF NASIONAL BAGI PENCIPTA DAN PELAKU MUSIK DI INDONESIA” (2017) 32:2 Justitia Pax.

Raihana, Mangaratua Samosir, Bambang, Fhauzan Remon, “Analisis Yuridis Keberadaan Royalti Dalam Hak Cipta(Studi Ciptaan Lagu)” (2023) 3:5 J Soc Sci Res 7861–7868.

Ramadhan, Febriansyah et al, “INDONESIA’S FUTURE ACTING PRESIDENCY: MAINTAINING OR REPLACING THE NEW ORDER LEGACY” (2024) 10:1 Verit Justitia 30–59.

Ramadhan, Febriansyah, Sunarto Efendi & Ilham Dwi Rafiqi, “Penentuan Jenis Produk Hukum dalam Pelaksanaan Putusan Mahkamah Agung tentang Hak Uji Materil (Kajian terhadap Tindak Lanjut Putusan Mahkamah Agung 28 P/HUM/2018)” (2022) 11:1 J Rechts Vinding Media Pembin Huk Nas 55–76.

Risky, Saiful, Sholahuddin Al-Fatih & Mabarroh Azizah, “Political Configuration of Electoral System Law in Indonesia from State Administration Perspective” (2023) Volksgeist J Ilmu Huk dan Konstitusi 119–130.

Sardjono, Agus, “PROBLEM HUKUM REGULASI LMK & LMKN SEBAGAI PELAKSANAAN UNDANG-UNDANG HAK CIPTA 2014” (2016) 46:1 J Huk Pembang 50.

Scharf, Nick, “The evolution and consequences of digital rights management about online music streaming” (2022) 42:1 Leg Stud 61–80.

Shang, Lin, “Enjoy your online music carefully: collective management of music copyrights in the USA” (2015) 8:1/2 Int J Intellect Prop Manag 58.

Siangli Putri, Christine Vina Siangli Putri, Yati Nurhayati & Muhammad Aini, “Tinjauan Yuridis Pemanfaatan Ciptaan Lagu Secara Komersial Pada Restoran/Cafe Dalam Peraturan Pemerintah Nomor 56 Tahun 2021 Tentang Royalti Hak Cipta Lagu Dan/Atau Musik” (2023) 4:1 J Penegakan Huk Indones 119–128.

Sudjana, “EKSISTENSI DAN KEWENANGAN LEMBAGA MANAJEMEN KOLEKTIF (LMK) DALAM PERSPEKTIF HUKUM INDONESIA” (2020) 6:1 J Huk Sasana 16–40.

Suwadi, Pujiyono, Andi Chaerul Sofyan & Rifqi Setia Ramdhani, “Legal Comparison Between National Collective Management Institutions in Indonesia and United States” (2024) 18:4 Rev Gestão Soc e Ambient e04572.

Suzuki, Akira, “Community unions in Japan: Similarities and differences of region-based labour movements between Japan and other industrialized countries” (2008) 29:4 Econ Ind Democr 492–520.

Theresia, Margareth, Septhian Eka Adiyatma & RA Nidha Nadia, “Civil Law in Indonesia and Russia: Easy and Affordable Access to Legal Aid” (2023) 4:3 J Law Leg Reform 6.

Villiger, Ralph & Martin W Bauer, “Valuation of complex license contracts” (2009) 15:4 J Commer Biotechnol 301–308.

Vira Nur Maharani & Dwi Desi Yayi Tarina, “Wewenang dan Tanggungjawab Lembaga Manajemen Kolektif Nasional (LMKN) Dalam Perlindungan Hak Ekonomi Musisi Indonesia” (2024) 5:1 J Interpret Huk 881–888.

Zhang, Zijian, “Rationale of Collective Management Organizations: An Economic Perspective” (2016) 10:1 Masaryk Univ J Law Technol 73–112.